“The integration of heart and mind, soul and intellect, within the context of our tradition has often escaped me…this search led me to the work of Rabbi Shagar, and his work introduced me to a new language for a new generation,” writes Aryeh Rubin, director of Targum Shlishi, in “The Sacred Literature of Rabbi Shagar,” his preface to the volume Rabbi Shagar, Faith Shattered and Restored: Judaism in the Postmodern Age (Maggid Modern Classics Series, 2017). The preface is reproduced in full below.
Targum Shlishi supported the translation into English of this collection of essays. This volume is the first authoritative collection of Rabbi Shagar’s work in English and is considered by the publisher to be a major contribution to contemporary Jewish discourse. A major focus of Rabbi Shagar’s work was his ongoing endeavor to put forth a religious and spiritual response to postmodernism. The publisher is offering Targum Shlishi’s readers a discount on the book, as explained below, in the “Book Discount” section.
Rabbi Shimon Gershon Rosenberg (Shagar) (1949–2007) was one of Israel’s leading thinkers, known for his innovative and creative spiritual approach. A religious Zionist scholar and teacher, he founded and headed Yeshivat Siah-Yitzhak in Efrat, Israel. He grew up in Jerusalem and, until now, his body of work has been known primarily within Israel. In addition to teaching, he authored several books that focused on Talmud, Jewish philosophy, and contemporary religious society in Israel.
The publisher credits Shagar with helping to shape “a generation of Israelis who yearn to encounter the Divine in a world progressively at odds with religious experience, nurturing religious faith within a cultural climate of corrosive skepticism.”
In his preface, Rubin quotes one of Rabbi Shagar’s students, the psychologist Dr. Yitzchak Mandelbaum, who summed up what many feel about these teachings with the comment, “I knew I had found what I didn’t know I had been searching for.”
The book is edited by Dr. Zohar Maor and translated by Elie Leshem, with an afterword by Rabbi Shalom Carmy, and it is a joint project between Maggid Books and the Institute for the Advancement of Rabbi Shagar’s Writings. The volume was published by Maggid Modern Classics Series, which publishes work by the premier thinkers of the Modern Orthodox/Religious Zionist community.
Form and Function
The book gathers and translates into English ten essays that strongly represent Rabbi Shagar’s groundbreaking spiritual approach and that will resonate with Jews in the Diaspora, who must contend with the many challenges that modernism and postmodernism present to religious life. Six of the essays are drawn from Shagar’s major philosophical work Tablets and Broken Tablets, and two are from his book We Will Walk in Fervor, with the remaining two essays from his writings on the holidays (Hanukka and Sukkot). Topics considered in these essays include Rav Kook, Rav Nachman of Breslov, Wittgenstein, Lacan, and Lyotard. In addition, Rabbi Shagar explores issues of faith, certainty, freedom, justice, nationalism, mysticism, and love in these writings.
In commenting on his body of work, shortly before his death Rabbi Shagar wrote that he “devoted the bulk of my efforts to developing a personal-existential discourse that by its nature appeals to the individual whose position is often in conflict with the demand to repair society. Yet, to my mind, the rectification of the personal must also bring about an elevation of the social realm…I have come a long way toward that longed-for solution, even if what I wrote still falls far short of perfection.”
Cultivating Spirituality in the Face of Challenges
Aryeh Rubin feels that Rabbi Shagar’s distinctive and creative approach to the modern world is critically important for our time because of its realistic and honest approach to postmodernity complete with its complexities, challenges, and opportunities. Rubin notes that the rigid approach to Judaism taken by the previous generation has its faults, as he writes: “My generation failed in its mission of synthesis; by demanding a religious certitude based on fixed and rigid systems, we failed to integrate the realities of the modern world with the individual religious and spiritual needs of today’s Jews. I hope the teachings of Rabbi Shagar will be assimilated into the mindset of the next generation of Jewish leaders, who will utilize these tools—along with the neglected and marginalized philosophies of other great modern Jewish thinkers—to disseminate a Judaism more relevant for the new era.”
Related Articles/Further Reading
“Israel’s Paradoxical Man of Faith, Deconstructed,” by Elie Leshem, The Times of Israelis a fascinating article that presents a conversation about Rabbi Shagar between Leshem, the book’s translator Dr. Zohar Maor, its editor.
“God, Torah, Self: Accepting the Yoke of Heaven in the Writings of Rav Shagar,” by Levi Morrow, Lehrhaus.com is a comprehensive introductory article to the work of Rabbi Shagar.
The publisher has generously offered our readers a 25 percent discount on the book. Simply go to this link and enter the promotion code: MAGGID25.
The full text of the Preface is reproduced here.
Preface: The Sacred Literature of Rabbi Shagar
Like many of my generation who grew up in the Modern Orthodox world of the 1950s and 1960s, I have often needed to work hard to reconcile the conflicts of modernity with Jewish life and to integrate the modernist mindset with some of our difficult-to-reconcile ideologies. This quest led me to the work of many great thinkers: I studied the philosophies of Rabbi Kook while a student in Yeshivat Merkaz HaRav in the early 1970s, and as a layman in my later adult years, I explored the works of the thinkers Emmanuel Levinas and Yehezkel Kaufmann. Yet the psychological and spiritual strains between the modern world and some of the Jewish belief system remained ever-present. The integration of heart and mind, soul and intellect, within the context of our tradition has often escaped me.
As I entered my seventh decade, this search led me to the work of Rabbi Shagar, and his work introduced to me a new language for a new generation. In his philosophy, the strict doctrine of the yeshiva world is challenged; his is a Judaism that focuses not on obedience, but on how the text and the law relate to the individual. Using the tools and language of the postmodernist, Rabbi Shagar helps the reader relate to the world around him, engaging the student in a stimulating dialogue that allows for a much richer spiritual experience.
Until now, Rabbi Shagar’s works were known mostly within Israel; very few were available in English. So when asked to help subsidize the translation of some of his more approachable works, I immediately agreed. The anglophone world should appreciate this volume; after all, as an audience at once more individualistic and less integrally involved in the nationalist collective than their Israeli brethren, English-speaking Jews should resonate deeply with Rabbi Shagar’s sensitivity to the individual’s search for an independent approach. Rabbi Shagar’s views are in complete opposition to the doctrinaire philosophy force-fed to many within the American yeshiva system: an approach that relies on top-down authority and leaves little room for the exploration of individual spiritual needs. I believe that many readers will be assuaged both psychically and spiritually by the enveloping and open-minded philosophy of Rabbi Shagar.
In a documentary on Rabbi Shagar by Israeli television in 2012, one of his students, Dr. Yitzchak Mandelbaum, a clinical psychologist, astutely summed up his discovery of the teachings of Rabbi Shagar as follows: “I knew I had found what I didn’t know I had been searching for.” And so it has been for many who have incorporated his teachings into their worldview.
Perhaps Rabbi Shagar attained this heightened sensitivity through his own struggles and suffering. His mother went through the Holocaust. From this he learned that the world is often a bad, cold place offering no personal security. While he was serving as a soldier in the Yom Kippur War, his tank took a direct hit in battle with the Syrians; two of his yeshiva buddies were immediately killed, and he was badly burned – an event he hardly ever spoke of, but which raised in him questions of faith. As a student of the works of Rabbi Kook and Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, he reportedly said Rabbi Kook lacked that gnawing pain of extreme religious doubt. Rabbi Nachman, on the other hand, was suffused with doubts, helping Rabbi Shagar tackle his own questions.
This sensitivity to the inherent conflicts within modern Judaism endowed Rabbi Shagar with the tools to reach many young students seeking intellectual and spiritual renewal. His unique fusion of a fresh and existential reading of classical Jewish texts, contemporary thinkers, the great Jewish and non-Jewish philosophers, and Hasidism addressed the growing sense of alienation within the younger generation of modern religious students, a fact rarely admitted in the yeshiva world.
The Jewish religious establishment was allergic to the concept of deconstruction – the postmodernist mode of textual analysis that parses the critical gap between text and meaning. Rabbi Shagar, on the other hand, saw this approach as an opportunity for the student to be released from the shackles of religious cliché, ideology, and convention, and to relate to religion as an ongoing existential dialogue that is more than just an institution of formal laws. Whether addressing the depth of one’s relationships, the concept of forgiveness, or romantic love, Rabbi Shagar’s writing blends Jewish thought with the works of secular philosophers, encouraging his students to seek a more authentic spiritual truth. As Rabbi Shagar explained, study is not only about what the Talmud says, but about how it speaks to the individual student. Even more stunningly, while always disappointed when a student who did not find his place within this spiritual world left the path of observance, Rabbi Shagar maintained warm relationships with those who questioned and rejected.
For those who chafe against the broad, grand arguments and dogmatisms of the prevailing Orthodox doctrine: Take comfort in Rabbi Shagar’s postmodernist melding of theories and his new paradigm of learning and understanding our Jewish texts. While Rabbi Shagar’s approach encourages religious observance and a vibrant dialogue with tradition, it lacks the dogmatic security of previous generations. My exposure to the works of this great man did not lay to rest the bulk of my ongoing questions. It did, however, provide me with some solace and a modicum of harmony for the mind and soul.
I believe a new Jewish way of living is evolving. Where it will go, nobody knows.But the process is already well underway, and Rabbi Shagar’s work provides seedlings for the sprouting of this Jewish way of life.
My generation failed in its mission of synthesis; by demanding a religious certitude based on fixed and rigid systems, we failed to integrate the realities of the modern world with the individual religious and spiritual needs of today’s Jews. I hope the teachings of Rabbi Shagar will be assimilated into the mindset of the next generation of Jewish leaders, who will utilize these tools – along with the neglected and marginalized philosophies of other great modern Jewish thinkers – to disseminate a Judaism more relevant for the new era.
September 4, 2016
Rosh Chodesh Elul 5776
Targum Shlishi, a Raquel and Aryeh Rubin Foundation, supports projects that seek to create positive change in the Jewish world.
Faith Shattered and Restored is the part of the Maggid Modern Classics series, which publishes works by the premier thinkers of the Modern Orthodox/Religious Zionist community.